Judge sides with Ottawa Community Housing over tenant snow-clearing duties
![Snow Shovel Snow Shovel](/content/dam/ctvnews/en/images/2015/2/2/snow-shovel-1-2217027-1671815080443.jpg)
Ontario's top court has dismissed a case brought by an Ottawa mother and son after a dispute over snow-clearing duties under their lease agreement with the Ottawa Community Housing Corporation (OCH).
- Sign up now for our daily CTV News Ottawa newsletters
- The information you need to know, sent directly to you: Download the CTV News App
OCH denied liability in the legal action involving Daniel Crete, who claims he was injured in March 2017 after falling on ice on the front step of a row house that he and his mother, Marguerite Crete, were renting.
According to court documents, the Cretes alleged the corporation was responsible for winter maintenance at their leased property, including the clearing of ice and snow at the front step.
OCH claimed the Cretes, as the tenants of the property and signatories of the lease, were responsible for snow and ice clearing, citing a provision added to their lease that assigned the winter cleaning duties to the tenants in the area that Daniel fell. The corporation countersued against the family for contribution and indemnity for any amount it is ordered to pay.
Marguerite Crete and her late husband had been leasing the property since 1988, but argued in her initial case before the Ontario Superior Court of Justice last year, that the provision was inconsistent with Ontario's Residential Tenancies Act (RTA), and should be voided.
Justice Heather Williams ruled last year the provision in the lease was not inconsistent with the Residential Tenancies Act (RTA) and held that it required the family to handle winter maintenance in the area where Daniel fell.
Williams stated in her ruling that a section of the RTA which requires landlords to maintain a property in "good repair," did not extend to snow and ice removal. The judge applied another section, which requires tenants to maintain cleanliness, including snow removal, for the exterior common areas regularly used by the tenant.
The case was dismissed and the family appealed their case to the Court of Appeals for Ontario, who agreed the provision assigning winter maintenance duties of areas regularly used by the tenants was legal under the RTA and did not conflict with the law's general maintenance rules.
The judge also ordered the family to pay for the costs of the appeal to OCH in the amount of $15,000.
In an emailed statement, OCH said it could not discuss specifics related to the case, as it remains subject to ongoing litigation.
"OCH respects the legal process and complies with all relevant laws and regulations governing landlord-tenant relationships and affordable housing initiatives in Canada," a spokesperson for the organization said.
"We can share with you that maintenance information, including ice and snow removal, is provided to tenants upon lease signing and in various forms of communication throughout their tenancies. Ottawa Community Housing regularly reviews its policies and procedures to align them with our commitment to providing safe and affordable housing and current laws and regulations."
OCH provides offers approximately 15,000 homes to about 33,000 tenants across the National Capital Region.
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
![](https://www.ctvnews.ca/polopoly_fs/1.6943621.1719510587!/httpImage/image.jpg_gen/derivatives/landscape_800/image.jpg)
Watch Live Now: Canadian analysis ahead of the CNN Presidential Debate
U.S. President Joe Biden and former president Donald Trump are set to go head-to-head tonight in the first of two planned presidential debates. Here's how to watch the CNN Presidential Debate, Power Play's pre- and post-debate specials, and follow along in our real-time CTVNews.ca live expert analysis and commentary by debate and body-language experts.
'Hanging on for her life': Sask. family desperate to bring home sick niece from Philippines
For half a decade, a Saskatoon family has been trying to bring their orphaned niece to Canada, they say now it’s a matter of life or death.
'No additional flights will be cancelled': WestJet avoids strike as feds order binding arbitration
A potential strike by WestJet airplane mechanics would upend travel plans for 250,000 customers over the Canada Day long weekend, the airline says — and cost it millions of dollars.
BREAKING Nunavut judge sentences Toronto woman to 3 years prison for Inuit identity fraud
A Nunavut judge has sentenced a Toronto woman to three years in prison in a case of Inuit identity fraud.
Canada's top court rejects appeal from Sask. man who murdered wife
The Supreme Court of Canada has rejected an application from a Saskatoon man who murdered his wife.
Where do new Canadians come from? India and Philippines take top spots
Canada has welcomed more than 3.9 million new citizens since 2005, with nearly one third coming from India, the Philippines or China, according to a CTVNews.ca analysis.
Marilyn Monroe's former Los Angeles home declared a historic monument to save it from demolition
Fans of Marilyn Monroe have won a battle to preserve her mark on Los Angeles and are a step closer to seeing a towering statue of the silver screen icon remain in Palm Springs.
Man charged with threatening to kill presidential candidates found dead as jury was deciding verdict
A New Hampshire man charged with threatening the lives of presidential candidates last year has been found dead while a jury was deciding his verdict, according to court filings Thursday.
AI regulation 'a start,' needs to 'have teeth': Hinton, godfather of AI, says
So-called godfather of AI Geoffrey Hinton says he's 'pleased' governments are starting to take artificial intelligence, and the possible regulations of it, seriously.