Canada's top court dismisses city of Ottawa's application to appeal Kanata golf course ruling
Residents living in Kanata Lakes promise the fight to protect the Kanata Golf and Country Club from development is "far from over", despite Canada's highest court not hearing the city of Ottawa's appeal on an agreement protecting the land from a housing development.
The Supreme Court of Canada dismissed the city of Ottawa's application for leave to appeal the Ontario Court of Appeal's decision to strike down parts of an agreement that protected the golf course and allowed ClubLink to proceed with the development.
The Supreme Court did not provide any reason for its decision not to hear the city's appeal.
In November, Ontario's top court ruled ClubLink has the right to build a housing development on the land, reversing a lower court ruling that would have banned the company from building a new subdivision on the site and protecting the golf course and greenspace.
The legal dispute involves the so-called '40 per cent agreement,' the 1981 agreement signed between the then-city of Kanata and developers stating at least 40 per cent of the property must be kept as green space.
"It's certainly frustrating. We felt that it needed to be looked at by the Supreme Court," Coun. Cathy Curry told Newstalk 580 CFRA's Ottawa Now with Kristy Cameron. "I've continually said it's not about golf, it's not even about Kanata Lakes, it's about agreements and long-term land agreements in particular.
"They decided not to look at it; however, it's not the end of the road for all of us at all."
The Kanata Greenspace Protection Coalition says it is disappointed, but not surprised the high court will not hear the case.
"We understand that the City of Ottawa leadership had serious concerns about the impact of the Court of Appeal decision on a plethora of agreements both in place and in progress," KGPC Chair Barbara Ramsay said.
"They have been very good partners for the KGPC in this fight to preserve urban greenspace and so, today, we’re particularly disappointed for them. However, we continue to engage our legal team in managing a full slate of legal options in this fight and we will now buckle down to ready for our next step, a return to Superior Court on September 13 and 14."
In October, 2019, ClubLink formally applied to the city to build more homes on the golf course lands. ClubLink and its developers, Minto Communities and Richcraft Homes, promised a new community of more than 1,500 homes with a minimum 25 per cent greenspace.
In February, 2021, an Ontario Superior Court Justice ruled the '40 per cent agreement' between ClubLink and the city "continues to be a valid and binding contract." However, the Ontario Court of Appeal said the agreement was important, but not an ironclad protection of green space forever.
"The owners have operated the golf course for more than 21 years," the ruling said. "Neither the City’s right to a conveyance nor ClubLink’s right to a reconveyance have vested within the perpetuity period. As a result, these contingent interests in the golf course lands are now void."
City Solicitor David White said in November that the Ontario Court of Appeal's ruling means the city would no longer have a right to demand reconveyance of the land if ClubLink stops operating the golf course.
"However, the Court did not invalidate any other sections of the 40% Agreement (as requested by ClubLink), or any other agreement relating to the golf course."
White told council in November that pending further rulings:
- ClubLink still has an obligation to operate the golf course in perpetuity (section 5(1) of the 40% Percent Agreement).
- The City still has a right of first refusal if ClubLink tries to sell the golf course (section 5(3) of the 40% Percent Agreement).
- If ClubLink does sell the golf course, it must ensure that the new owner enters into an agreement to preserve the golf course in perpetuity
NEXT STEPS
The Kanata Greenspace Protection Coalition notes the Court of Appeal invited the city and ClubLink to discuss what impact the invalid clauses, struck down by the court, would have on the 40 per cent agreement. The city and ClubLink will appear before Ontario Superior Court Justice Marc Labrosse next month to look at the future of the remaining clauses of the agreement and whether the contract protects the land from development.
"Today, the Supreme Court of Canada denied leave on the City’s appeal in relation to the matter with ClubLink. In accordance with the court’s practice, reasons for their determinations were not provided," Acting City Solicitor Tim Marc said in a statement to CTV News Ottawa.
"While the Ontario Court of Appeal did strike clauses 5(4) and 9 from the original agreement, concerning the obligation to convey the golf course to the City if it were to no longer operate, the status of the balance of the agreement was remitted to Mr. Justice Labrosse."
The KGPC is also taking ClubLink to court over two "Restrictive Covenants" that limit how the land can be used.
"The fight is far from over," KGPC lawyer Alyssa Tomkins, partner at Gowling WLG, said. "Though the Supreme Court has refused leave to appeal, the matter is still proceeding before Justice Labrosse. We trust that the remainder of the 40% Agreement will be preserved by the court."
With files from CTV News Ottawa's Michael Woods
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
Most of Canada to receive emergency alert test today
The federal government will test its capacity to issue emergency alerts today, with the exception of Ontario, where the test will take place on May 15.
OPINION What King Charles' schedule being too 'full' to accommodate son suggests about relationship with Prince Harry
Prince Harry, the Duke of Sussex, has made headlines with his recent arrival in the U.K., this time to celebrate all things Invictus. But upon the prince landing in the U.K., we have already had confirmation that King Charles III won't have time to see his youngest son during his brief visit.
Ontario man devastated to learn $150,000 line of credit isn't insured after wife dies
An Ontario man found out that a line of credit he thought was insured actually isn't after his wife of 50 years died.
Boy Scouts of America is rebranding. Here's why they're now named Scouting America
After more than a century, Boy Scouts of America is rebranding as Scouting America, another major shakeup for an organization that once proudly resisted change.
New Canadian study could be a lifesaver for thousands suffering from CTE
A first-of-its-kind Canadian research study is working towards a major medical breakthrough for a brain disorder, believed to be caused by repeated head injuries, that can only be detected after death.
Rape, terror and death at sea: How a boat carrying Rohingya children, women and men capsized
In March, Indonesian officials and local fishermen rescued 75 people from the overturned hull of a boat off the coast of Indonesia. Until now, little was known about why the boat capsized.
Stormy Daniels describes meeting Trump during occasionally graphic testimony in hush money trial
With Donald Trump sitting just feet away, Stormy Daniels testified Tuesday at the former president's hush money trial about a sexual encounter the porn actor says they had in 2006 that resulted in her being paid to keep silent during the presidential race 10 years later.
These adults born in the '90s partnered with their parents to buy homes in Ontario
An Ontario woman said it would have been impossible to buy a house without her mother – an anecdote that animates the fact that over 17 per cent of Canadian homeowners born in the ‘90s own their property with their parents, according to a new report.
For their protection, immigrants critical of China and India call for speedy passage of Canada's foreign interference legislation
Canadian immigrants threatened by hostile regimes are urging parliamentarians to quickly pass the 'Countering Foreign Interference Act' so they can feel safe living in their adopted home.