Crown seeking new trial against eastern Ontario doctor acquitted of killing 4 patients
Brian Nadler (centre) leaving an Ottawa courtroom after being acquitted of murder and negligence charges on July 2, 2024. (Jackie Perez/CTV News Ottawa)
Crown attorneys are seeking a new trial against Brian Nadler, a doctor acquitted of murder charges last month in connection with the deaths of four patients at an eastern Ontario hospital, court documents show.
- Sign up now for daily CTV News Ottawa newsletters
- The information you need to know, sent directly to you: Download the CTV News App
Before his trial was set to begin on June 2, Nadler, 35, was cleared of four charges of first degree murder and negligence causing death in an unusual move by Crown prosecutors to call no evidence in the case and to ask an Ottawa Superior Court judge to acquit him.
Crown prosecutors asked for the acquittals after Justice Kevin Phillips had ruled to exclude some of the evidence that hinged on expert testimony and believed they no longer had a reasonable chance of conviction. Prosecutors said a stay or withdrawal of the charges would mean there would be no possibility of an appeal of the case in the future.
A notice of appeal was filed by Crown lawyers with the Superior Court of Justice in Ottawa on Tuesday, alleging Phillips made a mistake in excluding the evidence of the prosecution's expert doctor, limiting the evidence of another and admitting the evidence of defence experts.
Crown lawyers are asking the court to set aside the acquittals so a new trial can be ordered.
Nadler’s lawyer told CTV News on Wednesday the appeal had been expected.
"It's our view that the appeal is without merit and we look forward to the opportunity to respond in the Court of Appeal," said lawyer Brian Greenspan.
Nadler was charged in March 2021 with first-degree murder in connection with the death of Albert Poidinger, 89. A year later in August 2022, he was charged with three additional counts stemming from the deaths of Claire Briere, 80, Lorraine Lalande, 79 and Judith Lungulescu, 93.
He was later additionally charged with negligence causing death for the same patients.
Nadler, 35, was a doctor at the Hawkesbury and District General Hospital at the time. Nadler has maintained his innocence, saying the patients died of COVID-19.
Nadler, along with his mother and sister, launched a $20 million lawsuit against the hospital and several staff members shortly after his acquittal, including the hospital's CEO, chief of staff, a nurse and chief of general medicine at the time. The lawsuit is seeking damages for "defamation, abuse of process, conspiracy and wrongful dismissal."
In their statement of defence, the hospital and other defendants denied all allegations made by Nadler.
With files from CTV News Ottawa's Katie Griffin
Shopping Trends
The Shopping Trends team is independent of the journalists at CTV News. We may earn a commission when you use our links to shop. Read about us.
Ottawa Top Stories
-
SPECIAL WEATHER STATEMENTSPECIAL WEATHER STATEMENT Up to 5 cm of snow, freezing rain expected in Ottawa
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
Heavy snow, freezing rain warnings hit parts of Canada, expected to last throughout Monday
Significant snowfall and heavy rain hit parts of Canada on Sunday and the weather system is expected to continue into Monday morning and throughout the day.
BoC expected to lower interest rates again, with odds leaning toward larger cut
Financial markets and forecasters are betting on another jumbo interest rate cut from the Bank of Canada this week.
The Canada Post strike involving more than 55,000 has hit 25 days
The Canada Post strike involving more than 55,000 workers has hit 25 days.
Celebrities spotted at Taylor Swift's final Eras Tour performance in Vancouver
Taylor Swift fans from around the world gathered in Vancouver on Sunday to witness the final performance of her massively popular Eras Tour, including a few celebrities.
Government faces third Tory non-confidence vote ahead of potential fiscal hurdle
The Liberals are set to face a third Conservative non-confidence vote today, but the government is likely to survive with the support of the NDP.
U.S. should be concerned about illegal immigration from Canada: Canadian survey
More than 80 per cent of Canadians believe the flow of illegal immigrants from Canada to the U.S. is a concern, according to a new survey.
Jay-Z denies allegations he sexually assaulted a 13-year-old in 2000 with Sean 'Diddy' Combs
A woman who alleges she was sexually assaulted by Sean 'Diddy' Combs has amended her lawsuit to include allegations that she was also assaulted by Jay-Z at the same party.
Taylor Swift ends record-smashing Eras Tour in Vancouver, after glittering global run
Taylor Swift took the stage for the final time on her record-smashing Eras Tour, watched by tens of thousands of delirious fans in Vancouver's BC Place arena and by millions on livestreams around the world.
Syrian prime minister says government is still functioning but foreign and domestic challenges loom
Syria's prime minister said Monday that most cabinet ministers are still working from offices in Damascus after rebels entered the capital over the weekend and overthrew President Bashar Assad. Streams of refugees crossed in from neighboring countries, hoping for a more peaceful future.
Atlantic
-
Federal Government announces more than $1 billion to meet New Brunswick’s electrical needs
Natural Resources Canada announced it will spend more than $1 billion for the province of New Brunswick to meet growing electricity demands in a news release Sunday.
-
Dalhousie University study applies artificial intelligence to sustainable dairy farming
A researcher at Dalhousie University in Halifax is applying modern technology to ancient practice to identify trends in methane emissions from Canadian dairy farms.
-
The 61st annual Christmas Daddies Telethon raises more than $559,000 for children in need
The 61st annual Christmas Daddies Telethon continued its proud Maritime tradition, raising more than $559,000 for children in need on Saturday.
Toronto
-
Toronto police investigate deadly shooting in North York
Toronto police say they are investigating the death of a male found with gunshot wounds in a driveway in North York early Monday morning.
-
Will he or won't he? Signs that Ford may call an early Ontario election stack up
Inside Ontario's legislature, the halls are decked, the sounds of children’s choirs singing Christmas carols waft down the corridors, and in the air there’s a feeling of an election.
-
School bus cancellations in the GTA on Dec. 9, 2024
Freezing rain has led to school bus cancellations in some parts of the GTA this morning.
Montreal
-
This Ontario family's car was stolen in Montreal with their dog still in it
An Ontario family's car was stolen with their dog still in it. The car was found, but their furry friend is missing.
-
Police search for three men who escaped from immigration holding centre in Quebec
Authorities are searching for three Chilean nationals who escaped from the Laval Immigration Holding Centre north of Montreal.
-
Quebec reaches agreement in principle with home daycare workers, ending strikes
Quebec has reached an agreement with child-care workers who have been on strike for weeks.
Northern Ontario
-
Northern Ontario man sentenced for killing his dog
WARNING: This article contains graphic details of animal abuse which may be upsetting to some readers. A 40-year-old northern Ontario man is avoiding prison after pleading guilty to killing his dog earlier this year.
-
Winter weather travel advisory in effect for Sault, Sudbury, North Bay
Environment Canada has issued a winter weather travel advisory for Sault Ste. Marie, Sudbury and North Bay.
-
Canada's air force took video of object shot down over Yukon, updated image released
The Canadian military has released more details and an updated image of the unidentified object shot down over Canada's Yukon territory in February 2023.
Windsor
-
What’s lowering Detroit River water levels?
If you’ve noticed the current along the Detroit River sitting lower than usual, you’re not alone.
-
'They’re going through hell': TLC Foundation treats children with cancer to free shopping spree
The TLC Foundation invited over 200 children from southwestern Ontario to Toys R Us in London, Ont. for a free shopping spree.
-
Spits erase deficit to beat Saginaw
lya Protas and A.J. Spellacy each scored twice as the Windsor Spitfires erased a 3-1 first-period deficit to defeat the visiting Saginaw Spirit 7-4. Protas also chipped in with two assists and Spellacy had one helper in the OHL game.
London
-
Four-vehicle, fatal crash on Sunday
A 53-year-old from Toronto was pronounced deceased at the scene. Another driver was airlifted to a trauma centre. Two passengers were transported to hospital with non-life-threatening injuries, and two other drivers were not injured.
-
A change in precipitation to start the week, more snow on the way
The London area will get a bit of a break from the snow to start the week, but it's been replaced with rain. Temperatures will remain above zero with periods of rain continuing throughout the day on Monday with a chance for sunshine on Tuesday.
-
Roof of historic hotel collapses in Bayfield
A week’s worth of heavy snow coupled with rain overnight in Bayfield proved too much for the roof of the historic Albion Hotel.
Kitchener
-
Four-vehicle, fatal crash on Sunday
A 53-year-old from Toronto was pronounced deceased at the scene. Another driver was airlifted to a trauma centre. Two passengers were transported to hospital with non-life-threatening injuries, and two other drivers were not injured.
-
Two 16-year-olds charged with Brantford stabbing
Two Brantford teens are accused of a stabbing that sent the victim to hospital with serious injuries.
-
Wet week ahead with rain and snow in southern Ontario's forecast
You’ll want to bundle up and bring along an umbrella when heading out the door this week.
Barrie
-
Central Ontario school bus cancellations
Environment Canada has issued a freezing rain warning for our region.
-
Freezing rain warning in effect for Barrie, surrounding areas
After all the snowfall that hit Muskoka and Simcoe County over the last week, Barrie and many other parts of the region are under a freezing rain warning as of Sunday evening.
-
Pair of sleeping drivers charged in drug bust
Two drivers are facing charges after they were allegedly found sleeping in their respective vehicles and possessing a quantity drugs Saturday afternoon in Waubaushene.
Winnipeg
-
Road and school closures in place in Southern Manitoba due to snowy conditions
The winter wallop in southern Manitoba has prompted a number of highways and schools in Manitoba to be closed, and is resulting in several buses not running on Monday.
-
Wintery weather warnings in effect for southern Manitoba
Environment and Climate Change Canada has issued several snowfall, winter storm and freezing rain warnings for much of southern Manitoba.
-
Minnedosa residents urged to reduce sewage usage due to winter storm
People living in Minnedosa are being asked to reduce their sewage usage or risk a sewage backup in their homes and businesses.
Calgary
-
Man dead after incident at workplace in northeast Calgary
Occupational Health and Safety and the Calgary Police Service are investigating how a man died on Sunday night.
-
Some Olympic Plaza bricks can be saved, city now says
In a surprise move, the City of Calgary said Monday that there's a possibility that some of the thousands of commemorative bricks that make up Olympic Plaza can be recovered.
-
Hundreds of jubiliant Syrian-Calgarians celebrate end of Assad regime at city hall rally
Hundreds of Syrian Calgarians crowded into city hall Sunday, only instead of protesting for freedom, they were tasting it.
Edmonton
-
Family spokesman says slain Edmonton security guard had only been working 3 days
A spokesman for the family of a security guard who police say was murdered while patrolling an Edmonton apartment building last week says the man had only been on the job for three days.
-
Baby found dead in south Edmonton parking lot: police
Police are investigating the death of an infant in south Edmonton.
-
The Canada Post strike involving more than 55,000 has hit 25 days
The Canada Post strike involving more than 55,000 workers has hit 25 days.
Regina
-
Creativity for a cause: Lego showcase raises funds for White City library
The White City Community Centre held a showcase over the weekend – featuring brilliant and detailed creations from Saskatchewan's finest masters of building with Lego.
-
BoC expected to lower interest rates again, with odds leaning toward larger cut
Financial markets and forecasters are betting on another jumbo interest rate cut from the Bank of Canada this week.
-
Saskatoon honours Bella Brave with birthday celebration
It has been five months since Bella Thompson, widely known as Bella Brave to her millions of TikTok followers, passed away after a long battle with Hirschsprung’s disease and an auto-immune disorder.
Saskatoon
-
Saskatoon honours Bella Brave with birthday celebration
It has been five months since Bella Thompson, widely known as Bella Brave to her millions of TikTok followers, passed away after a long battle with Hirschsprung’s disease and an auto-immune disorder.
-
No injuries following kitchen fire in Saskatoon
Saskatoon fire crews responded to a kitchen fire on the 100 block of Avenue U South Sunday afternoon.
-
BoC expected to lower interest rates again, with odds leaning toward larger cut
Financial markets and forecasters are betting on another jumbo interest rate cut from the Bank of Canada this week.
Vancouver
-
Young Swiftie scores seat at sold-out Eras Tour after holding up sign outside BC Place
Thirteen-year-old Sidney Ha was among the throngs of Swifties without a ticket to the Eras Tour in Vancouver who gathered outside of a fenced-off BC Place Saturday night – but thanks to one stranger’s act of kindness, she ended up inside the stadium singing along.
-
Taylor Swift ends record-smashing Eras Tour in Vancouver, after glittering global run
Taylor Swift took the stage for the final time on her record-smashing Eras Tour, watched by tens of thousands of delirious fans in Vancouver's BC Place arena and by millions on livestreams around the world.
-
Celebrities spotted at Taylor Swift's final Eras Tour performance in Vancouver
Taylor Swift fans from around the world gathered in Vancouver on Sunday to witness the final performance of her massively popular Eras Tour, including a few celebrities.
Vancouver Island
-
Young Swiftie scores seat at sold-out Eras Tour after holding up sign outside BC Place
Thirteen-year-old Sidney Ha was among the throngs of Swifties without a ticket to the Eras Tour in Vancouver who gathered outside of a fenced-off BC Place Saturday night – but thanks to one stranger’s act of kindness, she ended up inside the stadium singing along.
-
B.C. NDP provincial director hospitalized after 'serious medical emergency'
The former B.C. NDP MLA for Chilliwack and newly appointed provincial director, Dan Coulter, is in hospital after suffering a “serious medical emergency,” according to the party.
-
Prince George Taylor Swift fans rent car after flight to Vancouver cancelled
A diehard Taylor Swift fan who lives in Prince George, B.C., says a flight cancellation forced her and a group of other Swifties to rent a car and make the near 800-kilometre journey to Vancouver to catch the last dates of the Eras Tour.
Kelowna
-
Study of 2023 Okanagan wildfires recommends limiting development in high-risk areas
A study into the devastating wildfires that struck British Columbia's Okanagan region in 2023 has recommended that government and industry limit development in high-fire-risk areas.
-
Kelowna, B.C., to host the Memorial Cup in the spring of 2026
The Western Hockey League's Kelowna Rockets will host the Memorial Cup in the spring of 2026, the Canadian Hockey League said Wednesday.
-
545 vehicles impounded in 332 days: BC Highway Patrol pleads for drivers to slow down
Mounties with the BC Highway Patrol in Kelowna say they've impounded more than 545 vehicles for excessive speed and aggressive driving so far this year. That works out to more than 1.6 per day.
