Legal proceedings ordered for Horizon Ottawa in connection with election expenses
A City of Ottawa committee has decided to commence legal proceedings against Horizon Ottawa following an audit into the group's expenses during the 2022 municipal election.
An audit was called following a complaint accusing Horizon Ottawa of benefiting from an event called "Horizonfest" in September 2022. Auditors found Horizon Ottawa appeared to have contravened three campaign finance rules under the Municipal Elections Act (MEA) relating to expenses incurred outside of the allowable campaign finance period and the collection of ineligible donations, which were not returned to the city.
- Sign up now for daily CTV News Ottawa newsletters
- The information you need to know, sent directly to you: Download the CTV News App
Horizon Ottawa describes itself as a municipal-focused grassroots organization whose goal is to cultivate local solidarity around socially and economically progressive priorities.
On Wednesday the Election Compliance Audit Committee approved legal proceedings against Horizon Ottawa, saying it would be in the public interest.
At issue is $947.24 worth of expenses Horizon Ottawa incurred outside the advertising campaign period related to the Horizonfest event, including a liquor license with an invoice dated June 17, 2022, a charge for a theatre stage with an invoice dated July 12, 2022, a tarp purchase dated Aug. 17, 2022, and a bank of phone credits found to have been made prior to the date of registration as a third-party advertiser. Auditors also found the anonymous cash donation jar that was used to collect money for the campaign during the event that totalled $448.15 and should have been returned to donors or to the City Clerk because Horizonfest did not meet the criteria as a fundraising event under the Municipal Election Act. The audit also said Horizon Ottawa's financial records were not appropriately maintained.
Horizon Ottawa maintains that it disagrees with the auditor's findings. At committee, Horizon Ottawa said that its understanding is that an expense is “incurred” when the good or service in question is used and that none of the expenses at issue were used prior to its registration as a third party advertiser. Horizon Ottawa also argued that the apparent contravention related to the donation jar was a simple misclassification in its financial statements and that it reported the amount and made no attempt to obscure any monies received.
The committee disagreed.
Minutes from the committee meeting outlined the decision.
"At the time it incurred the impugned expenses, Horizon Ottawa had not yet registered as a third party advertiser. It later changed its mind and opted to register. The Committee finds this decision flowed, at least in part, from Horizon Ottawa’s decision to have select municipal candidates participate in Horizon Fest. This made Horizon Fest a third party advertisement under the MEA. In that regard, the impugned expenses became campaign expenses, for the MEA’s purposes, upon Horizon Ottawa deciding to participate in the election as a third party advertiser. By incurring the expenses before the campaign period, Horizon Ottawa gained an advantage in its campaign activities. The MEA imposes a campaign period, in part, to prevent just such an advantage," the summary says.
"With respect to the other two apparent contraventions referenced in the audit report—collection of cash donations and deficient recordkeeping—the Committee accepts the auditor’s opinion that these items are apparent contraventions. Regarding the cash donations accepted at Horizon Fest, the Committee takes note of Horizon Ottawa’s written submission that it was entitled to accept anonymous donations under $25 in relation to third party advertisements as “contributions”. Accepting Horizon Ottawa’s submission at face value, Horizon Fest was in fact a third party advertisement regulated under the MEA."
The City Clerk has been directed to retain and refer the matter to an independent prosecutor.
In a statement following the meeting, Horizon Ottawa claimed the audit process had been "weaponized" against it.
"This has been nothing more than a fishing expedition started by someone who disagrees with Horizon Ottawa’s vision and mission," a media release said. "This process should not be permitted to be weaponized by the wealthy and well-connected in our city as a way to interfere with legitimate, transparent, democratic participation."
The group said it was disappointed with the committee's decision, but looks forward to vindication in court.
"We maintain that we acted with transparency and integrity throughout the 2022 election. We diligently prepared a financial return, underwent an audit by our own independent auditor and fully participated in the audit by the city-appointed auditor. As the report shows, there was never any attempt to obfuscate the nature of our revenues or expenditures or to characterize transactions in a particular way to gain an advantage," Horizon Ottawa said. "We are looking forward to being fully vindicated in the judicial proceedings to come."
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
Son charged with 1st-degree murder after father's death on B.C.'s Sunshine Coast
A 26-year-old man has been charged with first-degree murder in connection to the death of his father on the Sunshine Coast last year.
Loblaw using body-worn cameras at 2 Calgary stores as part of pilot project
Loblaw is launching a pilot program that will see employees at two Calgary locations don body-worn cameras in an effort to increase safety.
China is raising its retirement age, now among the youngest in the world's major economies
Starting next year, China will raise its retirement age for workers, which is now among the youngest in the world's major economies, in an effort to address its shrinking population and aging work force.
Trudeau says Ukraine can strike deep into Russia with NATO arms, Putin hints at war
Prime Minister Justin Trudeau says Ukraine should be allowed to strike deep inside Russia, despite Moscow threatening that this would draw Canada and its allies into direct war.
Driver charged with killing NHL's Johnny Gaudreau and his brother had .087 blood-alcohol level
The driver charged with killing NHL hockey player Johnny Gaudreau and his brother Matthew as they bicycled on a rural road had a blood-alcohol level of .087, above the .08 legal limit in New Jersey, a prosecutor said Friday.
Sisters finally see the Canadian 'aviation artifact' built by their father nearly 90 years ago
Two sisters have finally been reunited with a plane their father built 90 years ago, that is also considered an important part of Canadian aviation history.
What's behind the boom? The Manitoba community that nearly doubled in a decade
For decades, the Town of Ste. Anne was stagnant, but that all changed about 10 years ago. Now it is seeing one of the highest spikes of growth in the province.
Canadian warship seizes 1,400 kilos of cocaine off Central America
A Canadian warship has seized more than 1,400 kilograms of cocaine during an anti-drug-trafficking operation in Central America.
'I couldn't form the words': 23-year-old Ont. woman highlights need for rural health care after stroke
The experience of 23-year-old Muskoka, Ont., resident Robyn Penniall, who recently had a stroke, comes as concerns are being raised about the future of health care in her community.